10 Must-Read Crime Thrillers Better Than Gone Girl
With Gone Girl (2012), Gillian Flynn reshaped the crime thriller genre in her image. Front and center were domestic noir-tinged stories about feminine rage, anchored by vivid acts of violence that blew open the myth of a picture-perfect suburban marriage.
Years before tradwife horror became all the rage, Flynn infused her thrillers with housewives so brutal and unsatisfied that it felt impossible to look away from their dark, winding mysteries.
In the 14 years since Gone Girl, however, a new generation of brilliant women-centered crime thrillers has taken hold—so many, in fact, that Gone Girl now feels a little less singular. Crime thrillers are in the golden age of evil women.
Strangers on a Train
By Patricia Highsmith (1950)
Gone Girl is the modern classic that reshaped the crime thriller genre, but to fully appreciate its brilliance, it helps to have an understanding of what came before. Long before Gillian Flynn, the master of suspense was Patricia Highsmith, whose crime novels took such stark twists that they set the blueprint for decades of tropes. She may be best remembered for her Ripley series, but Strangers on a Train was her defining work of crime fiction.
Seven years before Agatha Christie thought to stage a murder on a passing train, Highsmith wrote two selfish, callous men crossing paths in one, where they hatch a plan to commit two untraceable murders. The men share no known connection, but each has a person he wants dead. Doing each other’s dirty work could be the perfect crime—if one of them doesn’t unravel before he can pull the trigger.
But this novel premise is only half the fun in this book that inspired one of Hitchcock's best films—it’s the slow, sinking dread leading up to the crime that makes this book unforgettable.
You can purchase Strangers on a Train here.
The Witch Elm
By Tana French (2018)
Many prolific crime novelists are posed as contemporaries to Gillian Flynn, but Tana French might be the most underrated. The Irish author is a master of procedural mystery series about small towns haunted by the unfamiliar taste of violence and cops who get so close to their cases that they start to question reality. But one of her best works—and the best entry point to her bibliography—is her sole standalone novel.
The Witch Elm feels singular not just because it's a standalone (most of her books can technically be read that way), but because it stretches the confines of the genre she calls home. Nothing is as it seems in this mystery, and no one is quite suited to solve it. Its narrator is both the victim of a recent crime and a suspect in one from long ago. Thanks to the brain injury he received in the second attack, he can’t recall whether he committed the first. The only other possible culprits are his immediate family members—and they each have a motive.
You can purchase The Witch Elm here.
I Have Some Questions For You
By Rebecca Makkai (2023)
Crime isn’t a typical genre for Rebecca Makkai, a Pulitzer Prize and National Book Award finalist for her epic historical fiction, but I Have Some Questions for You feels like the defining crime thriller of the true-crime era.
I Have Some Questions for You follows Bodie, a successful true crime writer still haunted by the murder of her boarding school roommate decades earlier. So when the school invites her to teach a masterclass in podcasting, and her intrepid students grow fascinated with the case, she can’t help but dive into the one true-crime story she shouldn’t be telling. What she finds might unravel everything she’s come to believe about the last 30 years.
Makkai builds her story against a classic murder-mystery backdrop—an isolated school plagued by the story of a student murdered on campus—but what she finds there is anything but familiar. Presented as part investigation, part interrogation, I Have Some Questions For You is a well-crafted crime thriller with a bigger project: forcing its readers to question what authority any one narrator has to tell the story of someone else’s death.
You can purchase I Have Some Questions for You here.
While We Were Burning
By Sara Koffi (2024)
Gone Girl redefined the suburban housewife crime thriller, centering both a feminist rage and a literary sensibility that would shape later fan favorites like Liane Moriarty’s Big Little Lies (2014), Celeste Ng’s Little Fires Everywhere (2017), and May Cobb’s All the Little Houses series.
While We Were Burning is a vastly underrated entry into that canon. Pitched as Parasite meets Kiley Reid’s Such a Fun Age, the novel follows Elizabeth, a housewife whose suburban Memphis life unravels when her best friend dies under mysterious circumstances, and that’s just the prelude to this story.
Trying to maintain some semblance of normalcy, Elizabeth hires a personal assistant, Brianna, who starts to fill the void her best friend left. But Brianna is hiding a loss of her own—one Elizabeth may have to pay for. This fast, searing novel holds true to the most fundamental trope in the suburban housewife thriller canon: that no one is exactly who they claim to be.
You can purchase While We Were Burning here.
Sisters of the Lost Nation
By Nick Medina (2023)
Since Truman Capote wrote In Cold Blood in 1965, writers have grappled with where the boundary lies between sensitivity and sensationalism when drawing inspiration from real acts of violence—especially when real-life justice has not been served. But somehow, Nick Medina’s horror-thriller overflows with suspense without ever feeling like anything less than a thoughtful tribute to the real-life Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls crisis.
In Sisters of the Lost Nation, high school senior Anna is haunted by a tribal legend about a dark entity that swallows people whole. Her fear seems justified when girls her age start to disappear in rapid succession.
But when her younger sister becomes the latest missing girl—and all signs point to a local casino so central to the reservation’s economy that its owners feel above the law—Anna resolves to face whatever force, supernatural or human, would make her disappear and silence any cries for justice. Part folk horror, part crime thriller, Sisters of the Lost Nation is a soul-stirring treatise on cultural belonging, who gets justice, and who has to create their own.
You can purchase Sisters of the Lost Nation here.
Death Takes Me
By Cristina Rivera Garza, translated by Robin Myers and Sarah Booker (2025)
Inspired in part by the real-life femicide crisis in her native Mexico, Garza makes a meal out of playing with structure in this murder mystery, but doesn’t sacrifice suspense.
Set in an unnamed city where a string of men have been brutally murdered and castrated, Death Takes Me stays memorable not just for the crime, but for Garza’s genius structural choice: the whole story is narrated by a literature professor who may have witnessed one of the attacks, or may have committed it.
The professor may be helping the police make sense of these attacks, committed by someone who leaves lines of poetry as a calling card—or, after years of writing about gendered violence, she may just be learning to justify it. The thrill of reading this novel isn’t in zeroing in on the killer, but watching the possibilities expand in front of you.
You can purchase Death Takes Me here.
Eileen
By Ottessa Moshfegh (2015)
Depending on who you ask, Ottessa Moshfegh is alternatively beloved and derided for her penchant for disgusting, brutal imagery. But that signature is never more useful than when she applies it to a crime thriller.
Moshfegh has experimented with murder mysteries more than once, including in her 2014 novella McGlue, narrated by a sailor who can’t remember if he committed the murder he’s accused of, and her 2020 novel Death in Her Hands, in which an elderly widow grows obsessed with a murder that may not have happened at all. But Eileen is her only outright crime thriller—and, perhaps because of this, her best book to date.
Eileen’s title protagonist is a young woman desperate to leave behind everything about her tiny New England hometown, most of all her alcoholic father and her dead-end job at a boys’ juvenile prison. Enter Rebecca, a glamorous, alluring prison psychologist who has grown obsessed with a patient accused of murdering his father. Rebecca may be Eileen’s chance at escaping this town for a bigger life, but she’s bent on a brutal form of justice, and keeping up with her may come at a violent cost.
You can purchase Eileen here.
Sharp Objects
By Gillian Flynn (2006)
Gone Girl is Flynn’s most memorable novel, but this is her most intricate. Where Gone Girl raced toward its record-scratch twist, with Sharp Objects, Flynn takes her time painting a portrait of a labyrinthine murder.
As much a Southern Gothic and domestic as a crime thriller, Sharp Objects slowly stretches out across the small Midwestern town where journalist Camille Preaker returns from Chicago to cover the recent murder of a young girl. Much like Gone Girl, the mystery we think we’re unraveling is just the tip of a very dark, very twisted iceberg.
You can purchase Sharp Objects here.
Girl Number 8
By Janice Okoh (2027)
Playwright Janice Okoh’s debut novel has already been compared to Tana French, Oyinkan Braithwaite, and Karin Slaughter, and all three appraisals are merited. Set in Nigeria, Girl Number 8 blends the thoughtfully written detective characters of French’s Dublin Murder Squad and Cal Hooper series with the creeping class divides of Little Fires Everywhere, but applies them to an even more chilling mystery.
When a domestic worker’s four-year-old daughter, Freida, disappears from the care of her wealthy employer, a prominent local politician, Girl Number 8 introduces us to a detective just as complicated, chaotic, and unforgettable as any of French's: Sola Adeyemi, an expert in ritual killings and the perfect mind for this case.
But just as Sola’s personal life descends into chaos, so too does this mystery: local superstitions, ritual sacrifices, and political corruption are all at play, and worse, Freida isn’t the only missing girl. With the election on the horizon, what starts as one disappearance becomes a race against the clock to unravel a sprawling conspiracy before the powerful people involved can throw Sola to the wolves.
Girl Number 8 releases January 19, 2027. You can pre-order it here.
Emerald Lake
By Nita Prose (2027)
Nita Prose cemented herself as a brilliant mystery mind with her Molly the Maid series, but her first standalone novel promises something all-new and just as enthralling.
An idyllic summer house is the one place elderly Jane Weber and her young granddaughters should feel completely safe, but Emerald Lake is anything but. Instead, when her granddaughters find human remains near the water, Emerald Lake becomes the most haunted place Jane could possibly be. Suddenly, she’s thrown back in time, forced to recall a fateful summer in 1955 that produced her first love, but also led to a tragedy she’s spent decades burying.
This new direction for Prose is about more than just solving a winding mystery. Where The Maid was about uncovering the truth and making it known, Emerald Lake reckons with the cost of sharing it. Revealing what she knows could destroy everything Jane has built—but she may not be able to live with keeping up the lie.
Emerald Lake by Nita Prose releases March 30, 2027. You can pre-order it here.